Hiring Strategy

Online Interviewing for Senior Financial Services Roles: What Works (and What Doesn’t)

February 19, 2026

Virtual interviews are now a strategic test of leadership, not just a hiring step.

Virtual interviewing is no longer a stopgap. In financial services, many senior hiring processes now begin – and sometimes end – online.

For strategic roles in risk, compliance, legal and commercial leadership, that shift has changed more than logistics. It has changed how judgement, influence and credibility are assessed.

The question is no longer whether senior leaders can be evaluated online. It’s whether organisations are doing it well.

Table of contents

What Works

  1. Clarity Before Conversation

Senior candidates don’t want exploratory, vague discussions.

Before a first interview, they should understand:

  • The mandate of the role
  • The reporting line and governance structure
  • The current regulatory or commercial pressure points
  • What success looks like in 12 months

 

When context is clear, the conversation becomes strategic rather than surface-level. Without it, interviews risk drifting into generic career walkthroughs.

 

  1. Structured, Outcome-Led Questions

At leadership level, experience is assumed. What matters more is how someone thinks.

Strong virtual interviews focus on:

  • Decision-making under regulatory pressure
  • Navigating competing stakeholder priorities
  • Balancing risk appetite with commercial growth
  • Influencing boards or executive committees

 

Structured questioning not only improves assessment quality, but it also reduces bias and ensures alignment across panel members. Online settings can actually sharpen discipline here. With less small talk and fewer environmental distractions, conversations often become more focused.

  1. Panel Alignment

One of the biggest pitfalls in virtual hiring is internal fragmentation.

Multiple stakeholders join separate calls. Themes overlap. Questions repeat. Candidates are left wondering what each stage is testing.

High-performing hiring teams align beforehand:

  • Who is assessing technical depth?
  • Who is evaluating strategic judgement?
  • Who is focusing on cultural and stakeholder fit?

 

When roles are defined, interviews feel cohesive and intentional.

 

  1. Professional Communication

Senior professionals expect clarity.

That means:

  • Clear timelines
  • Transparent process stages
  • Prompt follow-up
  • Honest feedback where possible

 

In competitive markets, silence speaks loudly. Candidate experience at senior level travels quickly within the industry. Virtual processes remove geographic friction, but they also increase visibility. A disorganised process is more noticeable when everything is digital.

What Doesn’t Work

  1. Treating Virtual as Informal

There can be a temptation to treat online interviews as casual screening calls.

For strategic roles, this is a mistake.

Candidates are assessing leadership quality, internal alignment and organisational maturity from the very first interaction. Tone, structure and preparation all signal standards.

  1. Over-Indexing on “Presence”

Gravitas can be harder to read through a screen. But it’s important not to confuse camera confidence with leadership capability.

Some highly effective risk and compliance leaders are measured, reflective and not naturally performative.

Assessment should focus on clarity of thinking and depth of judgement, as opposed to energy levels on Zoom.

  1. Disjointed Stages

When virtual processes stretch across too many unstructured conversations, fatigue sets in.

Each stage should have a clear purpose:

  • Initial strategic alignment
  • Technical or regulatory depth
  • Stakeholder and board-level fit

If every round feels similar, the process loses impact and strong candidates may disengage.

INSIGHTS

Market, talent & leadership insights.

View all

Ready to make the right move?

Whether you’re growing your team or planning your next career move, we’re here to help you get it right.